Cost Evaluation of Renovating a Deteriorated Two-Bedroom In-Law Suite

Cost Evaluation of Renovating a Deteriorated Two-Bedroom In-Law Suite


# The Renovation Adventure of a Two-Bedroom In-Law Suite in Honolulu

Having vowed to avoid remodeling endeavors after a tough fixer-upper project from 2019-2022, I unexpectedly found myself initiating another renovation adventure in the summer of 2025. This time, it was a dilapidated two-bedroom, two-bathroom in-law suite connected to my parents’ residence in Honolulu. The unit, approximately 900 square feet in size, represented not only a significant emotional investment but also a sizable financial one.

## Background and Reasons for the Renovation

The in-law suite was formerly owned by my aunt, who passed away in 2020, and it had remained unused since about 2013. Throughout the years, it endured severe water damage, pest problems, and general neglect. Entering the suite for the first time before the renovation began, I quickly recognized the extensive work needed – it virtually required an entire gut renovation.

The main motivation for the renovation was to create a comfortable living space for my elderly parents, aged 79 and 77. This suite would accommodate a caretaker or serve as residence for my family during visits. Considering that a standard rental for a similar size in a resort could be substantially more expensive, this renovation turned into a cost-effective option while ensuring closeness to my parents and enhancing their accessibility.

## Initial Budget vs. Actual Expenditures

I initially predicted the renovation would cost approximately $25,000, necessitating around 30 hours of management work. However, as with most remodeling endeavors, reality turned out to be more intricate.

– **Initial Budget**: $25,000
– **Actual Expenditures**: $40,685
– **Over Budget**: +$15,685 (63%)
– **Hours Spent**: 50 hours instead of 30

When adding the value of my labor, the overall expenses escalate to an estimated $58,000–$60,000. It’s evident that renovations frequently exceed initial estimates, a reality I had previously encountered.

## Cost Breakdown and Improvements Undertaken

Here’s a summarized overview of the costs incurred during the renovation:

1. **Debris and Trash Removal**: $4,500 (including tip)
– Four truckloads of accumulated items were cleared out.

2. **New Doors and Exterior Wood Trim**: $3,000
– Replaced decaying and termite-ridden doors.

3. **Water Heater Replacement**: $3,600
– Transitioned from a leaking system to a modern electric tank.

4. **Plumbing**: $10,500
– Although costly, efficient service enabled swift solutions, including addressing a persistent leak in my parents’ home.

5. **Cleaning**: $255
– I took charge of some detailing due to dissatisfaction with the cleaning services.

6. **Electrical Enhancements**: $2,500
– Managed by my handyman, ensuring vital safety upgrades.

7. **New Appliances and Furnishings**: $6,800 (washer, dryer, fridge, living and dining furniture)
– Quality choices were made during sales to better complement the unit’s aesthetic.

8. **Flooring**: $3,000
– Old carpeting was replaced with vinyl flooring for enhanced durability and look.

9. **Air Conditioning**: $1,780
– Three new AC units were installed to improve comfort in the humid environment.

10. **Painting and General Contracting**: Around $2,000
– A major portion of the painting was completed by me, saving money but requiring more time.

## Emotional Thoughts and Future Perspectives

Upon completion, the in-law suite evolved into a practical area that functions both as a family gathering place and as potential housing for my parents. The lighting is improved, plumbing issues have been resolved, and the overall aesthetics have significantly enhanced. This renovation, despite numerous challenges, helped fortify family connections and caregiving.

Recognizing the emotional significance of these projects and the rationale for investing in family living spaces is vital. This renovation can also be seen as a way to uphold the family’s legacy and secure a comfortable future for my parents in their later years.

Now, as we brace for a family visit, I hope that the long-anticipated appliances arrive safely. Given the value these improvements provide, there is a renewed sense of hope for our family’s prospects, resonating with a vision my grandfather had when he contemplated building a multi-generational living space many years ago.

Renovating may continue to pose challenges for me, but the rewards reaped from perseverance and dedication have turned into a space that truly feels like home.